In the question itself, of whether logic can be proved to exist or work, "proved" exempts a non-problematic notion of logic already, as does the overall question itself.
The question already assumes the existence and efficacious operation of logic, by using "prove" as a request for logically related reasons which infer something---namely, the truth of the statements "logic exists" and "logic works".
If logic did not exist and do what we want and idealize it to do, the question would hardly make sense anyway, in what it means to be a question, not to mention it's value or being obligated to believe its alleged truth-value indeterminacy or lack of existence or workability.
Questioning already uses logic to implicitly obligate an answer and have meaning for inquiring minds.
Tuesday, March 06, 2007
Hidden Prior Assumptions of the Notion of Evil
The existence of Evil as anything beyond mere human disdain or repugnance, requires a prior belief in an ultimate perfect standard of goodness, however tacit and unacknowledged that belief might be.
Wednesday, February 28, 2007
The Value of You
"It's important to tell those dear to us how we feel.
The opportunity can too easily be gone forever."
Ms. Marple (Agatha Christie, The Body in the Library)
The opportunity can too easily be gone forever."
Ms. Marple (Agatha Christie, The Body in the Library)
Tuesday, February 13, 2007
Harold and Nita: A Love Story
A letter I found today, inside the envelope containing my Mother's will:
Oct. 23, 1991
Dear Harold,
Had I many worldly possessions to leave you, they could never compare to the treasures of the heart that you have given me.
You'll never know how I depended on you for help and guidance, and you have never failed me.
You have graced every moment of my life and brought warmth to my heart.
You have eased every step and soothed every doubt. You have filled my days with joy beyond imagination and description. My strength was in your daily love.
I thank God for his gracious gifts to me in this earthly life, the most gracious of all, you, my life companion, my sustenance, my hope, my warmth, my one and only love.
Nita
Oct. 23, 1991
Dear Harold,
Had I many worldly possessions to leave you, they could never compare to the treasures of the heart that you have given me.
You'll never know how I depended on you for help and guidance, and you have never failed me.
You have graced every moment of my life and brought warmth to my heart.
You have eased every step and soothed every doubt. You have filled my days with joy beyond imagination and description. My strength was in your daily love.
I thank God for his gracious gifts to me in this earthly life, the most gracious of all, you, my life companion, my sustenance, my hope, my warmth, my one and only love.
Nita
Tuesday, January 30, 2007
The Operations Department of God's Mind
Without belief in God, reason becomes more clearly theistic.
Friday, January 19, 2007
Factual Intuition
Hastings: I've never known you to place much faith in intuition.
Poirot: "Intuition, Hastings, often describes some fact that is so deeply buried in the subconscious, that the subject is not aware of its existence."
Hastings: "What fact?"
Poirot: "Tres Biene, Hastings. If I knew that, the case---it would be solved."
(Agatha Christie, "The Underdog")
Poirot: "Intuition, Hastings, often describes some fact that is so deeply buried in the subconscious, that the subject is not aware of its existence."
Hastings: "What fact?"
Poirot: "Tres Biene, Hastings. If I knew that, the case---it would be solved."
(Agatha Christie, "The Underdog")
Tuesday, January 02, 2007
Definitional Ruling Factor Gone Wild
Any ruling factor used to claim evil as real beyond mere individual repulsion, is just as vulnerable to many atheistic objections as the belief in God itself.